Top Posts of 2011
Here are your five favorite posts of the year, based on number of unique visitors. As always, I have not included the Supernatural link roundups because of their inherent draw to readers and because they just don’t have a huge archival value.
Final Thoughts on Season 6 of Supernatural
In this post, Katie shares her reactions to a shaky season of Supernatural. Based on how the show treated the brothers and the fans over the year, she decided not to make Supernatural appointment viewing anymore. A lot of you shared your thoughts on the matter, and we both loved the discussion.
The CW’s Secret Circle: How Does It Compare to the Books
Julie Harpin visited us to share her thoughts on The Secret Circle soon after its premiere. I enjoyed her post a lot because she compared the books (which I haven’t read) to the show as it had aired so far. Do you find that her predictions of what would stay and what would go remained true as the season progressed?
Is ‘Grimm’ the ‘Supernatural’ Killer?
In this post, I share my thoughts on the new show Grimm. I stand behind my initial review: that it is more enjoyable on a weekly basis than a bad episode of Supernatural. And, since we never know when Supernatural will be bad, Grimm is often the show Mr. PCC and I watch live.
Ten Reasons The Vampire Diaries Is Better than True Blood
Katie and I got together to create this list. I stand behind it, even though I still love True Blood. Maybe one of these days we’ll do a debate post where we go over the relative merits of both shows.
Why HBO Leads the Emmy Nomination Field
In this post, I go off on a tangent about my view of Hollywood economics. I firmly believe that the network model is dying and, in the future, the relationship will be between production studios and consumers of the shows—no middleman needed.
What did we learn from this list? Genre television is definitely our stock in trade here at Pop Culture Curmudgeon, and we both like to complain about what is wrong with the pop culture landscape.
Are your favorites on the list? We’d also like to know what you would like to see more of in 2012. Let us know in the comments.
![]() |
Like what you read here? Sign up to receive every post delivered to your inbox. |



