Should the First Season Suck?

I experienced the joy of streaming Netflix over my Xbox 360 last weekend.

I watched the entire first season of 30 Rock, which I didn’t catch the first time around.

Then I tried to watch the second season of Weeds. I loved the first season of Weeds, but I didn’t get to see the second or third seasons. When we got Showtime a while back, I was so excited to be able to watch Weeds again, but the fourth season was awful. No Conrad, no Heylia, Mary Louise Parker sinking into depths of bad motherhood that apalled me, and very little funny stuff. Because it was so awful, it ruined season 2 for me.

That made me think about other shows that had awesome first seasons:

• Chuck–continues to get better and better
• Big Love–totally meh since season 1
• Veronica Mars–continued to be awesome, but season 1 was definitely the best.
• Heroes–they keep promising me that it will get good again, but it has been disappointing since the anti-climactic season 1 finale
• Friday Night Lights–stuttered a bit in season 2, but definitely back on track with season 3
• Supernatural–same as FNL, had some issues in season 2, but they worked through them and it remains a solid show.

I also thought about shows I didn’t watch in their first season:

• Seinfeld
• Friends
• Gilmore Girls

These are three of my favorite shows of all time. Maybe the key to a show’s longevity and continued artistic growth is for me to only begin watching in season 2. Or at least for me to not really care about the show after season 1.

Really, I think the key is the premise. Gilmore Girls explored family relationships, and Seinfeld and Friends explored the relationships among groups of Friends as they tried to make lives for themselves. The other shows I mentioned didn’t have a premise that was sustainable.

Veronica Mars had a compelling overarching mystery that was hard to top in subsequent seasons. Supernatural was slightly less reliant on its overarching mystery the first season, but it struggled to find something as strong as the boys working to find their father in the second season. Thankfully, the CW gave them a season 3, and the show has gotten stronger since then. Heroes keeps trying to cover the same ground over and over again. (I mean seriously, think before you kill off a character with a useful power. Giving Isaac’s power to paint the future to Parkman is just tacky.) Friday Night Lights suffered from network interference during its second season.

But, Chuck is my star. I didn’t think its premise was sustainable, but they continue to put him in situations that work while keeping true to the character’s roots. Other showrunners could take a lesson from this show.

Be the first to like.

Like

Unlike

Related Posts:

Chuck versus the Boring Superhero Show

Last year, Heroes was appointment television, and Chuck was something I recorded to watch on the wasteland that is Tuesday night.

A few episodes into this season, I’ve become a flip-flopper. Chuck is now my favorite part of Monday night, and Heroes, well, I watch it, but while I’m reading or playing WOW or playing with the dogs. The unfortunate thing is that now I have to watch How I Met Your Mother on my computer Tuesday nights. (Perhaps I should ask for an HD-DVR for the living room for Christmas. I really prefer watching my TV on TV, as I’m sure I’ve mentioned before.)

My thoughts on last night’s episode of Chuck: I have never bought John Larroquette as a lady-killer, not on Night Court, and not now. But, I loved his character, and I think he brought the right level of smarm. Melinda Clarke was fun, but Sasha could have been played by anyone.

I love that Chuck is coming into his own and doing spy stuff rather than just flashing info for the big guys to take care of. I hope this moves toward him becoming a spy, an integral part of the intel team even after the new Intersect is built.

And I was shocked to see Bryce. I can’t wait for next week’s episode to see what he wants. No good can come of it.

My thoughts on Heroes: Well, I’m not sure I really have any. I did pay pretty good attention, even though I was reading and keeping the daggits occupied. But, when someone asked me what the ep was about, I really couldn’t give an answer. I said something like, “They went to the future a lot and people died.”

Here’s hoping the season picks up a little and involves fewer flash forwards. The future visit worked really well as an isolated episode in season 1, but I’m tired of it now.

Be the first to like.

Like

Unlike

Related Posts:

• Monday Poll Results
• Why HBO Leads the Emmy Nomination Field
• Allow me to introduce myself!
• Supernatural in the Wild West
• Life Is Too Short for Crappy TV