Should the First Season Suck?

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed or email. Thanks for visiting!

I experienced the joy of streaming Netflix over my Xbox 360 last weekend.

I watched the entire first season of 30 Rock, which I didn’t catch the first time around.

Then I tried to watch the second season of Weeds. I loved the first season of Weeds, but I didn’t get to see the second or third seasons. When we got Showtime a while back, I was so excited to be able to watch Weeds again, but the fourth season was awful. No Conrad, no Heylia, Mary Louise Parker sinking into depths of bad motherhood that apalled me, and very little funny stuff. Because it was so awful, it ruined season 2 for me.

That made me think about other shows that had awesome first seasons:

• Chuck–continues to get better and better
• Big Love–totally meh since season 1
• Veronica Mars–continued to be awesome, but season 1 was definitely the best.
• Heroes–they keep promising me that it will get good again, but it has been disappointing since the anti-climactic season 1 finale
• Friday Night Lights–stuttered a bit in season 2, but definitely back on track with season 3
• Supernatural–same as FNL, had some issues in season 2, but they worked through them and it remains a solid show.

I also thought about shows I didn’t watch in their first season:

• Seinfeld
• Friends
• Gilmore Girls

These are three of my favorite shows of all time. Maybe the key to a show’s longevity and continued artistic growth is for me to only begin watching in season 2. Or at least for me to not really care about the show after season 1.

Really, I think the key is the premise. Gilmore Girls explored family relationships, and Seinfeld and Friends explored the relationships among groups of Friends as they tried to make lives for themselves. The other shows I mentioned didn’t have a premise that was sustainable.

Veronica Mars had a compelling overarching mystery that was hard to top in subsequent seasons. Supernatural was slightly less reliant on its overarching mystery the first season, but it struggled to find something as strong as the boys working to find their father in the second season. Thankfully, the CW gave them a season 3, and the show has gotten stronger since then. Heroes keeps trying to cover the same ground over and over again. (I mean seriously, think before you kill off a character with a useful power. Giving Isaac’s power to paint the future to Parkman is just tacky.) Friday Night Lights suffered from network interference during its second season.

But, Chuck is my star. I didn’t think its premise was sustainable, but they continue to put him in situations that work while keeping true to the character’s roots. Other showrunners could take a lesson from this show.

0 people like this post.

Like 

• Visions of Winchesters: The Supernatural Blog Carnival, November 4 Welcome to the November 4, 2009, edition of Visions of Winchesters: The Supernatural Blog Carnival. I apologize for missing last week's carnival. As I mentioned earlier this week, I was out with the flu. Last Week's Episode This Week's Episode News Spoilers: On a separate page to protect the spoilerphobes......
• The New Year of TV I am looking forward to January as if it were the beginning of the new fall season. I can't wait to see how they explain the Kate/Peter relationship on White Collar. I am looking forward to seeing all of the loose ends get tied up on Lost. And our Winchesters......
• Pop Culture Roundup, February 11 So, my laptop spent some time in limbo these past few days, deciding whether it would die or whether it just needed a good reformat. The reformat worked, but I still need to do some work to get it to recognize that it does, indeed, have a DVD drive installed.......
• Lost Makes Me Feel Dumb I watched the season premiere of Lost last night, and as usual, it made me feel dumb for not paying better attention. I typically read or write while I watch tv, but this is a huge mistake with shows like Lost that have a ridiculously rich mythology and 30 Rock......
• OK. A Lotta Love for Friday Night Lights If you've ever thought about watching Friday Night Lights, tonight is the night to do it.If you've never thought about watching Friday Night Lights, try it tonight. You might like it, Mikey.This is the last new episode of the second season, and from what I hear, tonight's ratings will be......

• Turning Her On - The Ultimate Guide For Men When we talk about a sexual turn on, guys and girls are quite different. It's true that woman feel attracted...
• FT.com / Comment / Opinion - Remember the bottom billion in our brave new world This weekend an attempt will be made by world leaders to redesign capitalism. A new financial architecture will be put...
• Cheap Golfing: Getting on the Green For Less Golfing has always been a bit of an aristocratic activity. This has created a notion in the minds of many...
• Six Lessons Jack Bauer of 24 Can Teach Us About Money There aren't many shows I'm addicted to, but 24 is probably one of them. And even though the current season...
• Save Time, Money and Space in Over 80 Ways If you're looking for handy gadgets, tools and various items that can save you time, money or space (or all...